From the symptoms as described, I would suggest you need a new mechatronic unit and NOT a complete new gearbox. Your complaint would appear to be with the Audi dealer rather than Mercedes, but it may be difficult to pursue. I would seek the advice of a solicitor who specialises in such cases.
It is not clear from your post how old this car is, but at 36500 in July 2012 I am guessing it is out of manufacturer's warranty before this issue first occurred in June 2014? In which case, it would matter not a jot whether it was properly serviced or not...... As well as giving very poor service, it would seem this Audi dealer is blowing smoke up your ass.
Name and shame the Audi dealer.
It is not clear from your post how old this car is, but at 36500 in July 2012 I am guessing it is out of manufacturer's warranty before this issue first occurred in June 2014? In which case, it would matter not a jot whether it was properly serviced or not...... As well as giving very poor service, it would seem this Audi dealer is blowing smoke up your ass.
Name and shame the Audi dealer.